If you read *carefully*, all the folks here are trying to say that the book(s) is benefitory for *all levels* as a reference. This is what you said: "想適合任何的水平，興趣或需求，是不可能的事。". Here are some of (part of) the comments: -- 看過這套著作後，相信會對有興趣想往後學習紫微斗數的人仕有莫大的幫助！ -- 初學者或有點程度的讀者都能有受益
Could be my perception is wrong. Wanna say that my definition of "初學者" is knowing the basic rule of 安星法, characteristics of the stars, simple prediction on years.
I will classified myself as "有小小程度的讀者" only, and just would like voice out my comment. I did not say the book was bad, right? I just said it's not too much different from others. I did not "抹殺這本書的存在價值", right? Here is the logics: -- Most people are more or the less the same in this world. -- They all exist, and have their own value. It's pretty common sense that a person is not worth to exist in the world if he's not too much difference from others.
You just need to spare your time. Nothing special. I have read thousands of books till now. However, you will then have no time for other activities...
菜菜子
發表於： 2005/07/11 02:56am
下面引用由stevie在 2005/07/10 11:35pm 發表的內容： Could be the reason that I have already read hundreds of books on 斗數... Flipped some pages, but still can't arouse my interests. Rather, I bought another new book on 斗數. The author's ...
下面引用由stevie在 2005/07/10 11:38pm 發表的內容： Ah ah, I leave this question to Mr. 緣生. I am sure, he has put considerable effort on these areas as well... Or, you are asking 緣生 *not* to publish books on these areas. It's a business wo ...
There are quite some books out there talking about 星系. I did take some time study 易 as well. However, I don't want to comment here ... Anyway. My definition of 初學 could be different from you.
緣生
發表於： 2005/07/10 11:45pm
下面引用由stevie在 2005/07/10 11:38pm 發表的內容： Ah ah, I leave this question to Mr. 緣生. I am sure, he has put considerable effort on these areas as well... ...
Ah ah, I leave this question to Mr. 緣生. I am sure, he has put considerable effort on these areas as well... Or, you are asking 緣生 *not* to publish books on these areas. It's a business world, pals.
Could be the reason that I have already read hundreds of books on 斗數... Flipped some pages, but still can't arouse my interests. Rather, I bought another new book on 斗數. The author's surname is Chui, a taiwan author. Anyway, I am not saying Mr. 緣生's book are bad, but to me, it does not have anything special.
下面引用由stevie在 2005/07/08 04:20pm 發表的內容： I do not intend to "attack" your publications. I have read all the articles in http://bbs.yuensang.com/cgi-bin/forums.cgi?forum=102 I think for beginners, it's okay. However, " ...
I do not intend to "attack" your publications. I have read all the articles in http://bbs.yuensang.com/cgi-bin/forums.cgi?forum=102 I think for beginners, it's okay. However, "不可多得的斗數研習參考書", I don't think so... at least for these two introductory books.
Expecting your coming publications, to have more *in depth* discussion on other aspects of 144宮四化飛星, 命主,身主, etc.
緣生
發表於： 2005/07/08 00:26pm
[這篇文章最後由緣生在 2005/07/08 12:31pm 第 1 次編輯]
下面引用由stevie在 2005/07/08 11:41am 發表的內容： Hmmm... how's the difference of the explanations/descripitions of this book from thousands of other 紫微books? I can find all these details in other books, and probably much more in depth. Th ...
Hmmm... how's the difference of the explanations/descripitions of this book from thousands of other 紫微books? I can find all these details in other books, and probably much more in depth. The book title suggests that it does not include 四化飛星, 命主,身主, etc. But it's just fine. You still can't convince me to take a look at this book, as it's just a "導讀" (introduction) only.
下面引用由rainbow在 2005/07/01 03:29pm 發表的內容： nlut, you can buy these books 紫微斗數and 八字 on the internet. click on the link below at , the website links at will direct you to online bookstores. 蔡老師作品 ...
一共是四個數字，如果看不清楚，請重新整理
所以要晚些才能在买. 不过很快我们就有新的讨论主题啦. 欢迎你来这里坐. 