| |
[這篇文章最後由rainbow在 2006/05/01 10:36am 第 2 次編輯]d6{hsY
儘管這部電影 "United 93" 太真和太痛苦，使美國人再面對一個5 年前 9.11 的大傷口，但是從美國電影評論家 (美國影評 97% 給極好的 review) 和 觀眾 獲得了極好的評論。5=&c<|
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 i
這部電影 "United 93" 前天 (2006 年 4 月 28 日) 在美國電影院上映.
IC8J8
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 :<LO
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 PdEN~
 此主題相關圖片如下：7a`)
 Mb}3"
 *f s.
 按此查看圖片詳細資料n
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 LKyGL
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 -k"b
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 #1S(g3
"  Who knew those heartless, shameless, money grubbing bastards in Hollywood could make a stunning and emotional film like this? It's never too soon to honor true American heroes. United 93 is clearly the first great film of 2006."
-- Michelle Alexandria, ECLIPSE MAGAZINE%jtU@
" ...a respectful, accomplished, non-exploitative piece of historical filmmaking ..."Zy C
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 r*wn
-- William Arnold, SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCERU~0Fm
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 hYd
" Greengrass has created an almost masochistic ritual that is hard to appreciate in a traditional cinematic way."1=3{
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 o26\
-- Josh Bell, LAS VEGAS WEEKLYO?BMja
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 caaWB
" Be prepared. United 93 is overwhelming, telling a story we've all come to know so very well. It will be one of the most affecting movies you'll ever see--if you can bring yourself to see it, that is."GmhBep
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 c\s3EE
-- Kit Bowen, HOLLYWOOD.COMk
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 !)/b
" The film could have watered the seeds of fear and hate inside us; instead, we found our hearts going out to people everywhere facing incomprehensible events."[}LpR
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 rF:P
-- Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat, SPIRITUALITY AND PRACTICEL:
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 PkC
" By sticking to the facts, Greengrass has created a surprisingly effective tribute to the heroism of common people and a cautionary tale that demands to be seen."g#"}(<
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Drn)J
-- Robert W. Butler, KANSAS CITY STARGO%.O^
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 @@_$8U
" we needed this movie"r-b1
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 IEl
-- Kevin Carr, 7M PICTURESD{?06
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 <vW
" Pure power."2ee!J"
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 `7@0A
-- Jeffrey Chen, REELTALK MOVIE REVIEWS*^kv$-
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 %C4+6l
" ...a gripping story of fanaticism, fear, heroism and the human animal in all its shadings."/OH
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 s2!?k>
-- Robin Clifford, REELING REVIEWSKu3SU"
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 -#m
" ... a gut-wrenching re-creation that represents a triumph -- a heartbreaking triumph, but a triumph nonetheless -- of you-are-there filmmaking. ",^Q
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 0u?]
-- Carol Cling, LAS VEGAS REVIEW-JOURNALjFu>N:
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 NiBJ
" Not since Bowling for Columbine has a movie left me so shaken up or so close to tears; that alone is a testament to Greengrass' achievement."FW"
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 TwwcM
-- Edward Douglas, COMINGSOON.NET@w#s5
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 pou
" With events as well known as these, Greengrass doesn't need to sensationalize. The film is more powerful when he un -sensationalizes."tN)U
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 (
-- David Edelstein, NEW YORK MAGAZINE2
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 GppqJ_
" The supposed centerpiece of the movie is its least involving part. There's a crude transition from the ground docudrama to in-air melodrama that occurs about halfway through."(6ajvS
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 |K;Ln
-- Dan Fienberg, ZAP2IT.COM3!O*?t
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 b
" Writer-director Paul Greengrass' United 93 is nothing short of a direct refutation of all the conventional Hollywood wisdom concerning how such a movie should be made."'j0=;W
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 4
-- Scott Foundas, L.A. WEEKLYaMyf
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 G.k;
" In its fitful remembering, United 93 raises important questions about the making of history."Tg0
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 ~L
-- Cynthia Fuchs, POPMATTERS-
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 5=z '
" Whatever monument is eventually built at Ground Zero or anywhere else, United 93 is as fitting and worthy a memorial to the victims and heroes of September 11 as one could hope for."NG
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 `Dg
-- Steven D. Greydanus, DECENT FILMS GUIDEej
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 f
" Paul Greengrass's United 93 is beyond devastating. His film about the events of Sept. 11, 2001, is all the more numbing because it is handled with such dignity and efficiency."}N$IfE
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 YI}J
-- Louis B. Hobson, JAM! MOVIESJxrI4b
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 yi(
" Many people feel United 93 is "too soon", and I certainly won't argue with anyone's need for time to heal. But when it isn't too soon, this film demands to be seen. "5
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 xJ0
-- Brian Juergens, FREEZE DRIED MOVIES_:k
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 l
" Writer/director Paul Greengrass has brilliantly and movingly threaded the needle."}QOc7
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 B=x7A0
-- Daniel M. Kimmel, WORCESTER TELEGRAM & GAZETTEQ:e
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 k
" ...defiantly star-less, defiantly deglamorized, defiantly devoid of Hollywood hero worship - and all the more riveting because of it.",v.
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 j'w(L9
-- Josh Larsen, SUN PUBLICATIONS (CHICAGO, IL)wBv/g
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 MsO`6
". .. for all its shock value, it is never exploitative, and it has something important to say."^b@u
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 c`7
-- Moira MacDonald, SEATTLE TIMES aQd
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 CzyP
" ...superb...haunting."!r
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 IJ6i
-- Tony Medley, TONYMEDLEY.COMg][b
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 #rqc
" It is a movie that takes us where we don't want to go but need to."~zX8
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 s
-- Roger Moore, ORLANDO SENTINEL)R,WLc
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 RHLk
" stands tall as it pays tribute to the Americans that gave their lives that day in the name of freedom"D*
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 J<MdWi
-- Sean O'Connell, FILMCRITIC.COM`b>
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究
" Intense, unflinching and well done."l';$pk
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 ]MG?5
-- Jeff Otto, IGN FILMFORCEZ
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 #m2
" Although the film has been made with great finesse, it is devoid of showbiz exploitation.""Gn2
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 &ys'>*
-- Peter Rainer, CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITORTW
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 i(
" Some human beings rise about the crowd in grandeur, leave a warm glow every time we think about them and imprint us with their nobility. United 93 shows us what GLORY is all about."}zJ
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Ggfmz
-- Diana Saenger, REVIEWEXPRESS.COM=NmKb8
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究
" A powerful and engrossing account undiluted by the sentimentality that often mars Hollywood depictions of history."_;16k
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Kl`
-- Pamela Troy, CULTUREVULTURE.NETn[`
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 cWL
" A testament as inescapable as the memorial now going up at Ground Zero."?\
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 enj
-- Rob Vaux, FLIPSIDE MOVIE EMPORIUM"/h
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 .P
" You can practically taste the tepid cabin air and smell the hodgepodge of colognes and deodorants of the passengers stacked beside you. You eye the terrorists with angst. Once the hijack occurs, you feel the fear pulsing throughout the plane."p{-P
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 bn
-- Phil Villarreal, ARIZONA DAILY STAR*8^
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 X
" United 93 is a tactful eulogy that could have been ravaged by a Jerry Bruckheimer-esque production of fiery explosions, Aerosmith tracks and Ben Affleck cameos."#^Q
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Fs9D}M
-- Mike Ward, RICHMOND.COMkn&?u_
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 :<i
" Intelligently and impeccably made ..."5jJ|
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 q7'
-- E! ONLINEgZ,Gty
" United 93 is one of the most important, necessary, and difficult films of our time."O5
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Z]
-- Gary Goldstein, REEL.COMnI9Q
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 &
" When I compile my Top 10 list of films for 2006, United 93 will be on it, and almost certainly close to the top."w
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 #U6mDk
-- James Berardinelli, REELVIEWSs*KU@+
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 cC
" Greengrass' own formidable version brings [the story of United Airlines Flight 93] to life -- and to death -- with a bluntness and nobility that are almost too hard to bear."g
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 aCJ^y
-- Amy Biancolli, HOUSTON CHRONICLE\^zD
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 a0ASTx
" ... you come out feeling that the filmmakers have done the right thing by this day."j
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 b
-- Ty Burr, BOSTON GLOBE^Ya@0
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 |p;*
" United 93 doesn't provide tidy answers or emotional catharsis, but it is a courageous exploration of painful issues.""7
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 so
-- Colin Covert, MINNEAPOLIS STAR TRIBUNE_=L3$
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 +`[
" ... beat for beat, the whole thing plays out very much according to the Hollywood playbook."|
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 3cC
-- Manohla Dargis, NEW YORK TIMESGIy
" A few people made extraordinary use of those tormented minutes, and United 93 fully honors what was original and spontaneous and brave in their refusal to go quietly."mI~
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 GT#1
-- David Denby, NEW YORKEREil
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 i4<
" Others have attempted to tell us about Flight 93, but Greengrass may have made the definitive account, allowing his movie to unfold in real time."cu3|@$
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 $
-- Robert Denerstein, DENVER ROCKY MOUNTAIN NEWS.W3-T
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 !|
" To watch United 93 is to be confronted with the grim chaotic reality of that autumn day in 2001."b!{N'
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 n6
-- Roger Ebert, CHICAGO SUN-TIMESO_n|je
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 <0OkCB
" ... United 93 is a riveting docudrama as compelling as it is odd."j
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 !
-- Rick Groen, GLOBE AND MAIL.??YO`
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 GP0n
" Greengrass has made not only a thoroughly fact-checked film but a film that uncontrovertibly comes from the heart."6K
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 z3d
-- Kirk Honeycutt, HOLLYWOOD REPORTERG}J0f
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 T|w
" United 93 may be the best movie I ever hated.":w14
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 0$1N
-- Ann Hornaday, WASHINGTON POST5$
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 2WfO
" ... this is a picture we all must see."-!E#C
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Mat
-- Peter Howell, TORONTO STAR`y%xD
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 8_F
" ... in telling the story of the one terrorist-commandeered jet that did not hit its target on Sept. 11, 2001, United 93 does so much right."_1%r
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 U}=No(
-- Lisa Kennedy, DENVER POSTkW
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 MAOaN
" ... a powerful and thoughtful dramatization of the terrorist crash of United Flight 93 ..."[#
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 :IY#A
-- Mick LaSalle, SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE#
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 )0
" Like most memorials, it is respectful, premised on competing obligations to the dead and the living, and eager to stress that the deaths were not in vain. It not only tells us we should never forget but also illustrates how we should remember."8o1t7"
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 qf$Rqb
-- Dennis Lim, VILLAGE VOICE9bst
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 >OV<_
" This is art engaging grim reality in the hope of perspective, understanding and perhaps even closure."IQ5Gz
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 usba:
-- Tom Long, DETROIT NEWS(['Yf>
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 &3T?
" It easily ranks as the best movie so far this year."V'0LYH
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 p
-- Bob Longino, ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONSTITUTION8
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 b-Zs
" Taut, visceral and predictably gut-wrenching."x}u%ky
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 _ODNF
-- Brian Lowry, VARIETYI6"
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 aj?_d
" For me, Paul Greengrass' meticulously researched movie was a deeply cathartic experience."}JA!
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 @YoS
-- Lou Lumenick, NEW YORK POSTE_5Sq"
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 K5WK*
" It is a docudrama done with great sensitivity, and with unerring judgment in the writing and in the depiction of the passengers and hijackers."\#3Zu
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 T.BvG
-- Jack Mathews, NEW YORK DAILY NEWS)&
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 w
" It's hard to imagine any American not being moved by this film."xhMx\B
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 0l
-- Bill Muller, ARIZONA REPUBLIC3
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 T8Pbt
" ... hard to watch, but impossible to turn away from."D
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 V $!p
-- Bruce Newman, SAN JOSE MERCURY NEWS&ZMV
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 {A
" The film is lean, harsh and remarkably free of cant."]l! 5>
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 $0@}
-- Michael Phillips, CHICAGO TRIBUNE["l<2
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 0*~AZ
" It is undeniably the most gut-wrenching and captivating film released this year."V}
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 3+>
-- Claudia Puig, USA TODAYZ
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 @]
" There's no way to watch United 93, Paul Greengrass' heartbreaking, pulse-pounding drama about the lone hijacked commercial airliner that failed to reach its target on Sept. 11, 2001, and not anticipate the dreadful outcome."2o
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Eg
-- Steven Rea, PHILADELPHIA INQUIRERS"lsn
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 zOH
" ... United 93 is an exemplary attempt to relive history, inspired and powerful."-
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 /.
-- Rex Reed, NEW YORK OBSERVERc6cj}K
" This is the best movie so far this year [and] I think it's the most important film."ai'.Bv
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 W
-- Richard Roeper, EBERT & ROEPER~eZh
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 $3@
" [Paul Greengrass] keeps a cataclysmic story scaled to the vulnerable men and women involved."aD)(
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 [t#%>
-- Lisa Schwarzbaum, ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLYI
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 N
" United 93 is a shattering, yet effective tribute to men and women who, when faced with unimaginable terror and all-but-certain death, dared to resist their fate using whatever they could get their hands on."ls{:
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 uK@:;
-- Gene Seymour, NEWSDAYr3
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 [Tcb(
" ... a monumental achievement that stands above any film this year."{
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 J8f
-- Peter Travers, ROLLING STONEDX1!{]
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 :_FH
" It's a mark of Greengrass' unequaled gift for believably re-creating reality that, once seen, it's impossible to get United 93 out of your mind, no matter how much you may want to."S0.eP
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 r,
-- Kenneth Turan, LOS ANGELES TIMES CYm
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 p@
" United 93 is an exhausting but commanding work of art."A:-
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 Y<
-- Chris Vognar, DALLAS MORNING NEWSe>bn
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 c
" ... a film that honors its subject with solemnity ..."VGn|
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 EF%y?p
-- Wade Major, BOXOFFICE MAGAZINE8X9Su
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 25_
" Reverent yet provocative ...".
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 UHF|k
-- Carla Meyer, SACRAMENTO BEE@6
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 1!
" Greengrass has managed to create a taut, extraordinarily haunting film."@EtK"Y
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 p
-- Rebecca Murray, ABOUT.COM0a
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 2|0<u~
" One of the most gripping and deeply upsetting films I've ever seen. I honestly left the theater shaking with a combination of anxiety, anger and sadness I haven't felt since the days immediately following 9/11."Ex_'a
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 DvO
-- Chuck O'Leary, FULVUEDRIVE-IN.COMP])}2F
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 0_4-~g
" The knowledge of what's to come allows Greengrass to build almost unbearable tension reinforced by his characters' ignorance% and later, their slow realization of what's going on."}S
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 DC
-- Keith Phipps, ONION AV CLUBWU|8
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 {
"There's nothing about United 93 that qualifies as entertainment in the traditional sense: It is an unpleasant, wrenching experience, which is just as it should be."t
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 k~
-- Rene Rodriguez, MIAMI HERALDZD
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 (d
" One hundred and eleven minutes: That's all the time it takes for a movie to go from indefensible to indispensable."*ic
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 9
-- Steve Schneider, ORLANDO WEEKLYkJHy0
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 B
" It's a sensitive, brilliant, uncynical re-creation, one that seeks not to exploit the dead but to commemorate them."J8oJ
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 n0b
-- Eric D. Snider, ERICDSNIDER.COMHk
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 m\ag
" A viscerally lacerating, emotionally wrenching experience...that melds the starkness of documentary with the power of drama."r>
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 &O
-- Frank Swietek, ONE GUY'S OPINIONs{7
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 chl[H
" United 93 is almost too much to bear. Greengrass softens none of the blows of these horrific events."K(FN
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 VJG-
-- Joshua Tyler, CINEMABLEND.COMu*Bc;
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 {N
" Good luck having a 'nice day' after leaving this film. You'll be an emotional wreck in need of a hug."cAk%
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 a/(vK8
-- John Venable, SUPERCALA.COM@g
©緣生術數研究社 -- 術數研究 -q#
" Greengrass has put forth a fine effort, eschewing hysterics and refusing to pander to those who would prefer a propaganda exercise to a serious film."0
| | |
|
|
|
頂端 
加到"我的最愛"
主題管理：
總固頂 
取消總固頂 
短訊息
查看
搜尋
通訊錄
引用
回覆
只看我
2006/04/04 05:10am 
IP: 已設定保密